The Utopia of Reality. Realisms in architecture between Ideology and Phenomenology

Proposed on the occasion of the first congress of soviet writers in Moscow in 1934, the notion of realism coming about in the theoretical debate on architecture in the early Thirties of the Twentieth Century appears to be an ambiguous notion, straddling between idealism and ideology, innovative research and historicist formalism. The failure of socialist realism and the crisis of its emphatic and monumentalist architectural imagery, clearly shows the utopian character of the realist “dream”, but also, in some ways, its imaginative power of striving to build a better world. After the Second World War the question of realism comes into discussion again. Especially in Italy realisms turns into an alternative to the modern paradigm, no less utopian, but open for the emerging postmodern American ideas as well as to the architecture of the «Tendenza». The paper proposes a survey on 20th century realisms as an instrument of reflecting the current state of architecture: after the excesses of the postmodern populism, the disillusionment of the “Architettura Razionale” and the dialectics of reconstruction – deconstruction, a new spectre of “Realism” as a way to react to the current architectural and urban condition seems to emerge in architecture again.